Photo Illustration of author's son, Zack, walking on a wooded path, by Luis G. Rendon/Globe Staff; Photo Courtesy of Whitney Ellenby

The article: Why I always announce my son’s autism

Why it’s a problem: I have to admit that I never heard of Whitney Ellenby before, but as soon as I started reading this essay by Ellenby in The Boston Globe, I immediately had a bad feeling in my gut, and it’s not just because she is overly enthusiastic about Steven Pinker. Nor is it because Ellenby incorrectly attributes the idea of common knowledge to Pinker, an idea which has been well established in the field of Political Economy. Doing an internet search, I was not surprised to find widespread criticism and distrust of Ellenby in the autistic community.

Unfortunately, Ellenby hasn’t seemed to have learned from those criticisms over the years. In her new essay in The Globe, she writes that whenever she takes her son Zack into public spaces, she feels compelled to announce to the world that he is autistic.

Ellenby writes, “My husband assumes that because autism has become so prevalent in media coverage and TV and movie depictions, bystanders who see Zack’s strikingly atypical behavior will surely conclude that he has autism. As Pinker would put it, my husband assumes that autism is common knowledge, and therefore no explanation is owed when a young man behaves in ways so obviously incongruent with his age.”

“I assume the opposite,” writes Ellenby, somewhat glibly. “From my perspective,” she writes, “the only common knowledge when my son bursts into a public space with objectively frightening volume and gestures is that his behavior is inappropriate.”

But, consider that if disabled people were allowed to speak our truths in the media rather than being spoken about, and if disabled people were more visible in the community, and trusted as the experts on ourselves, then maybe communities could rely less on people like Ellenby to tell them about autism.

There are two important sources of “common knowledge” to analyze here. One comes from the media sphere, including journalists, medical professionals, and self-proclaimed authorities like Ellenby, who not only uses her son’s experiences as opportunities to “educate” the public but also wrote a book about autism that was widely panned in the disability community. In this essay, Ellenby dissimulates her role as a media figure by reframing it as her role as a community member. It is from community, which is the second source of “common knowledge,” through familiarity and interaction, that knowledge is built from the ground up. Unfortunately, Ellenby’s understanding of community seems about as shallow as her understanding of autism.

I should note that I’ve met many “profoundly autistic” people like Zack who exist and live in the community every day, and it’s precisely this normalizing of disability in public spaces that allows common knowledge about disability to be built in community with others, which is why Ellenby is at least correct that disabled people must be given the supports and resources to live with autonomy in the community, rather than being hidden away or institutionalized. Unfortunately, by presuming that she speaks for disabled people, and by exploiting her son’s experiences as opportunities for knowledge dissemination rather than knowledge creation, Ellenby contributes to the disability community’s invisibilization and erasure.

It’s in this context of community and mutuality that it’s notable that Ellenby admits that “every time I enter a public space, I’m effectively forcing my lived experience onto strangers.” In essence, Ellenby is admitting that she does not see Zack as engaging in mutual knowledge sharing and creation with others in the community, but rather, she sees her role as imposing her knowledge upon others. It’s important to remember that it’s in this context of not acknowledging Zack’s agency that Ellenby has been most strongly criticized in the past by the autistic community.

In 2018, Aaden Friday wrote, “Whitney Ellenby tells us about the time she physically restrained and dragged her 5-year-old autistic son to see Elmo perform at a ‘Sesame Street Live!’ show. She describes fighting off his fists, pinning him down, and inching — her son shrieking and flailing, trapped between her legs — toward the auditorium’s entrance, an effort, she claims, ‘to save him from a life entrapped by autistic phobias.’”

As Friday notes, the media sphere is full of stories about disability, written by nondisabled people “at the expense of the vulnerable and marginalized community they claim to be advocating for.”

It’s also curious and almost fascinating the way that Ellenby insists on centering herself in her accounts of the public’s interactions with Zack, a framing that reveals much about her intentions – a need to make it all about her. The repeated use of words and phrases like “I” and “my lived experience” suggests that Ellenby sees herself as the main character in Zack’s story.

What’s curiously missing from Ellenby’s concept of common knowledge, however, is precisely a strong sense of community, which Ellenby exploits for a good story almost as much as she exploits Zack. Ellenby only talks about places where Zack is treated as a curiosity and is made a spectacle, and in the communities that she describes, there don’t seem to be any people who have known Zack for a long time. She calls them “bystanders” instead of fellow community members.

Tellingly, Ellenby neglects to discuss what happens when people in the community share knowledge, when everyone’s voice is heard, and how this builds trust and safety. It should be clear, then, that one of the problems with reflexively announcing to the world that your son is autistic and designating yourself as the authority on autism is that you are preemptively disallowing people in the community to know autistic people on their own terms. Despite claiming to be a member of the community, you are using your influence as a media figure to preemptively shape other people’s understanding about autism. This is especially problematic, because time and time again, those who have touted themselves as experts on disability and have presumed to speak for us, have so often gotten it wrong.

Ellenby compares herself to the boy who speaks the truth in the fairy tale, The Emperor’s New Clothes. She seems to have a very inflated sense of her importance in the disability community, though I can confidently say that Ellenby is no expert on disability, nor an ally. At one point in the essay Ellenby even writes about how she worries that people might think her son Zack is “mentally ill and dangerous,” thus reinforcing harmful stereotypes about another stigmatized group of people with disabilities.

Allowing disabled people to exist in the community is the best way to build safety and trust. Parents can certainly play an important role in this regard, but it’s important that people like Ellenby understand that she doesn’t speak for autistic people, she can only speak on behalf of her son. “Authentic social acceptance,” which Ellenby claims is one of her goals, will only be achieved when the voices of the disabled community are no longer spoken over by people like Ellenby.

Source: The Boston Globe