Zendaya stars in this year’s feature ‘The Drama.’ A24/Courtesy Everett Collection

The article: My Son Was Killed at Sandy Hook. ‘The Drama’ Showed Me Every Warning Sign We Keep Missing

Why it’s a problem: I feel for the parents and families who have lost children to mass gun violence. I’m also wary of op-eds that pretend to be about preventing school violence but are really about promoting pseudo-scientific threat assessments and pre-crime tools that demonize disabled, Black, and brown students.

It’s not a coincidence that after federal and state laws were enacted in the 1980s and 1990s mandating integration of disabled students in regular school settings, there was an increasingly reactionary response from nondisabled, mostly white parents and teachers that manifested in a salvo of fearmongering op-eds throughout the 2000s and 2010s framing disabled students as violent monsters wreaking chaos in their classrooms. Concomitantly, organizations like Sandy Hook Promise have pushed school-based threat assessments that have disproportionately targeted disabled and Black students, often resulting in their expulsion. This pattern is similar to the reactionary response by white people after the civil rights gains made by Black people in the 1960s, which manifested in policies of mass incarceration in the 1980s, under the Reagan and subsequent administrations, particularly the Clinton administration.

This op-ed by Nicole Hockley in The Hollywood Reporter follows the same template that she has used consistently over the years in numerous op-eds, which are high on emotional appeal and short on empirical evidence. Hockley intersperses the alleged “warning signs” of a potential mass shooter throughout her essay:

  • violence — whether directed outward or inward
  • isolation and disconnection
  • people who are bullied
  • consumption of media steeped in school-shooting culture
  • lack of meaningful support from community
  • sense of invisibility
  • hints of depression
  • despair
  • suicidal thinking
  • access to a rifle or other firearm
  • withdrawn
  • troubling comments
  • lack of belonging
  • change in appearance

This set of warning signs, almost verbatim, has been formally adopted in school and university threat assessment policies across the country. The problem is that it combines and conflates two different sets of students — disabled students and mass shooters — and it’s hard to believe, given the foreseeable consequences, that this was never the intended purpose.

From a standpoint of more effectively preventing mass shootings and school violence, it would make more sense to split this list into two distinct groups. To prevent violence, a list should include the following warning signs:

  • violence directed at others
  • access to a rifle or other firearm
  • expressions of intent to harm others

I think “expressions of intent to harm others” is more accurate and thus more actionable than “making troubling comments,” which is what Hockley originally wrote, which is too ambiguous and has frequently resulted in disabled students being wrongfully accused and punished. ProPublica reports that Tennessee recently passed legislation to fix its school threat assessment laws after too many disabled students and students of color were being wrongly accused of being potential mass shooters “over jokes and misunderstandings.”

For the second group, I would include the following indicators:

  • isolation and disconnection
  • people who are bullied
  • lack of meaningful support from community
  • sense of invisibility
  • hints of depression
  • despair
  • suicidal thinking
  • withdrawn
  • lack of belonging
  • change in appearance

For this group, I would recommend voluntary consultation with the student and if requested, increased individualized supports.

Unfortunately, organizations like Sandy Hook Promise have put school administrations in a bind, as administrations have become increasingly worried about legally liability if they don’t remove students expressing any of the above “warning signs” even though such “warning signs” are not reliable indicators of violence.

I don’t necessarily disagree with Hockley when she says that “when a young person feels seen, supported and connected, outcomes change.” The statement is a bit rose-colored and facile, but what is certainly problematic about it, is the strong implication that students who are struggling are at risk of becoming mass shooters. The consequences of such false logic should be obvious: privileged white students, who are the most likely to commit mass shootings, are the least likely to fall under the lens of threat assessment, while students from negatively racialized and other marginalized communities, who are more likely to struggle, to express anger and grievance, are therefore more likely to be labeled as threats and liabilities. The consequences have been dire.

When you follow the false logic of threat assessment and label distressed students as risks, then the predictable action to be taken by school administrators will not be to provide more supports to students, but rather to criminalize, exclude, and punish, which is exactly what has been happening across the country. And unfortunately, we are currently living under an administration whose policies have further eroded the minimal supports that existed for marginalized students, for Black students, LGBTQ students, and disabled students. We can expect students in these communities will struggle. Therefore, we can expect that these students will be criminalized under existing threat assessment algorithms.

As Nicole Nguyen notes, “Although students receiving special education services make up 18% of the student population, they accounted for 56% of the threat assessments. Additionally, youth of color account for 2.6% of the student body, yet 9.6% of threat assessments. Both sets of statistics reflect national trends in school-based policing that disproportionately targets students of color and students with disabilities.”

There are indeed some reliable warning signs of imminent school violence, including acquiring a firearm, making explicit threats, and expressing racist or white supremacist ideology. It’s significant that Hockley doesn’t mention the latter in her list of “warning signs,” given how often school shooters have endorsed such views.

When threat assessment tools cast a wide net, it’s not hard to understand that the purpose of such programs is not to prevent mass shootings, but rather to expand policing of already marginalized communities.

Source: The Hollywood Reporter